Buckatabon Supper Club Pop-Up at Hilldale

The Northwoods meet the Capitol during this exclusive pop-up of Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club at Café Hollander Hilldale. For three nights only, guests are invited to make a limited reservation for this one-of-a-kind supper club experience in Madison.

Inspired by the multi-generational, family-run restaurants in Wisconsin’s Northwoods, Frank & Larry’s Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club drips with “Up North” nostalgia. Their from-scratch menu and drink program feature familiar favorites, as well as modern twists on Wisconsin tradition. From Old Fashioneds and a relish tray, to our “World Famous” Prime Rib and a post-dinner ice cream drink, this prix-fixe pop-up menu features all of the classics.

Cozy up with your significant other, or celebrate with your “quaranteam” and enjoy fine food with a modern take on a quintessential Wisconsin institution–the Supper Club–at your neighborhood Café Hollander Hilldale.

Exclusive seatings for the supper club pop-up are available for one weekend only:

  • Friday, March 26
  • Saturday, March 27
  • Sunday, March 28
Dinner For Two: Supper Club Menu

Welcome Cocktails
Buckatabon Old Fashioned for each guest

Choose an Appetizer to Share
Mush Cargo
Baked jumbo mushrooms stuffed with Italian sausage, thyme, parmesan, garlic-whipped cheese, and topped with a pistachio crumble and herb aioli

Black Garlic Burrata
Local BelGioioso burrata cheese, black garlic crema, coiled cucumber, fenugreek, butter cashews, radicchio, and frisse served with black garlic olive oil, with toasted rye

Classic Relish Tray to Share

Individual Wedge Salads with Trio of Dressings

Choose Individual Entrees
“World Famous” 12 oz. Queen Cut Prime Rib
Slow-roasted, herb-rubbed Prime rib au jus with classic Yorkshire pudding, horseradish-smoked sour cream, and a baked potato

Crab & Brie Stuffed Salmon
Spice-rubbed Atlantic salmon stuffed with crab, brie, garlic, and herbs served over a hash of wild rice, asparagus, sweet peppers, and herbs in a tarragon-pepper sauce with pistachio crumble

Choose Ice Cream Drink to Share
Brandy Alexander
Grasshopper

Supper Club Pop-Up Details
Menu Pre-Order

When purchasing your tickets, choose from a selection of carefully curated menu items featuring favorites from Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club.

Themed Experience

For one weekend only, two private dining rooms at Café Hollander Hilldale will transform to create a cozy Supper Club vibe with nostalgia and charm.

Ninety Minutes

You’ll have 90 minutes to enjoy your supper club dining experience. Please arrive no more than 5 minutes early to check-in, due to limited indoor capacity and waiting areas.

*Please contact party@lowlandsgroup.com with any allergies or dietary restrictions or if you would like to dine with another party (Maximum of 6 people are allowed to be seated together at one table)